Sometimes American gets it wrong because of the way someone looks or is (Adam Lambert eg) and the great people get kicked off - who's voting is it little girls / Grandmas / middle aged people - take everything into account here - it's a popularity contest really that does not actually pick the most talented and unique - that's why some of these kids go into oblivion once the show is done. Most get dropped from the label if the music doesn't sell - that's Idols true testimony. Does the music sell after idol is over? I don't know about you but I've purchased 4 CDs is all the Idol seasons - Kelly Clarkson - Daughtry - Carrie - and Crystal - and if you want to see a kid perform check out Allison Iraheta on You Tube - that girl us an incredible performer - The End
I've watched Idol over the years since it's a cultural phenomenon, but this year was the worst. Without Simon Cowell around, all they did was praise the talent, so "America" was clueless about who was talented. Several of those voted off were so much better than those country bumpkins singing terrible songs all the time that it made the entire show much easier to ignore. Also, except for a few of the first winners everybody who has won the last half-dozen of these has been pretty forgettable. Yeah, maybe ratings were up a but, but there are more people in the world watching TV, too.